“When everyone in an organization accepts responsibility, shows respect and holds each other accountable to do the right thing through caring confrontation, everyone wins.” Gus Blanchard
One of the most overwhelming negative feelings a person can have is that of being put-down and shunned. The outsider feels alienated and lonely, not being accepted, loved, or respected by others. Such mental maps and feelings can have a major effect on the way a person views the worth of their lives and how they interact with their culture and fellow citizens. Let’s look at two recent mass shootings– Walter Reed-Fort Hood and Columbine. It all started for Maj. Nidal Malik at Walter Reed Army hospital in Washington,D.C. He had difficulty making friends. The doctor seemed aloof and distant said one of his colleagues. Girl friends or a possible wife search ended in no connection. His religious beliefs supported the male role of domination and authoritarianism. He began to see the world in a dualistic manner –you were either a believer or condemned to Hell. Patients were complaining about his questionable therapeutic practices and strange conversations. His colleagues saw warning signs. The precipitating factor for Maj. Nidal Malik action seems to be his frustration and anxiety about his pending deployment orders to go to Iraq. He wanted to be excused from serving in Iraq because of his Muslim beliefs. In addition. fellow doctors at Walter Reed, who had worked with him for four years have reported that from the beginning he had not made a very good first impression and the staff had many discussions about his performance and suitability to become a full fledge psychiatrist. The medical staff was very worried about this guy and yet no one step-up in caring way to stop him from being promoted and moved on to Fort Hood. He lacked interpersonal skills and was perceived uncooperative ( late for work many times) and unfriendly. He did not do a good job as a psychiatrist in training, was repeatedly warned, you better shape up, or, you know, you’re going to be in trouble. Trouble never came. He continued to be late for work, did badly in his classes, seemed inattentive to patients and outspoken and belligerent about being Muslim, For example he once gave a lecture at Grand Rounds one day that really caused concern because on the rightness of suicide bombing and wrongness of the US occupation. This incident freaked a lot of doctors out. Where dozens of the medical staff come into an auditorium, and somebody stands at the podium at the front and gives a lecture about some medical or academic issue or clinical practice; you know, what drugs to prescribe for what condition. But instead of that, Hasan gave a long lecture on the Koran and talked about how if you don’t believe, you are condemned to hell. Your head is cut off. You’re set on fire. Burning oil is burned down your throat. This lecture was not about educating or informing his audience about the Koran or Muslim culture because he came across as a “true believer” in the support of terrorism. When questioned by an audience member about his position and views he stared the guy down. We now know the rest of the story about his promotion to Major and his being passed on to Fort Hood where his stress, alienation and angry intensified because of harassment and rejection of requests to be re-classified as a conscienious objector so Irag deployment would be haulted. No one cared enough to confront these issues in an assertive and constructive way. He was left on his own to grow his “paranoid” theories of his fellow soldiers being his enemey and anger toward them and their way of life increased. And now many suffer and grief for the 13 soldiers gun down that horrific day at Fort Hood.
Eric Harris, one of the shooters at Columbine High School in Littleton, Colorado, in 1999 wrote in his suicide note to the community, “Your children who have ridiculed me, who have chosen not to accept me, who have treated me like I am not worth their time are dead.” A classmate of Dylan Klebold, the other shooter, said, “Dylan really felt unloved. He wasn’t so bad. He was lonely.” Incidentally, both Harris and Klebold were A students.
The Fort Hood and Columbine shootings are an extreme case of alienation and irrational thinking erupting into violence against innocent others. We will never know how other aspects of these mass murder’s relationships, families, and mental health and psychological makeup affected them or tipped the scales into anger, shooting and tragedy.
We will continue to debate how such tragedies can be averted and how much of a role organizational culture, interpersonal rejection and individual perceptions play in these tragedies. we know that an atmosphere that nurtures respectful relationships and confronts inappropriate behavior in caring, assertive and forth right ways can make a difference in stopping senseless, irrational, violent and destructive acting out but it takes someone with courage to stand-up and confront them in a caring but forceful way.
All across the world, people shoot “zingers, sarcasm, put-downs and disrespect one another daily. The consequences of these actions can go beyond a general feeling of unhappiness among the scorned and alienated targets, causing these outsiders to become paranoid, angry and engage in violence, or join extremists groups to feel a sense of belonging and acceptance. Continue reading ‘The Art of Caring Confrontation-Solutions for Fort Hood and Columbine shootings?’